ShmoopTube
Where Monty Python meets your 10th grade teacher.
Search Thousands of Shmoop Videos
ELA 5: Rocking a Debate 88 Views
Share It!
Description:
Bring your best amp and your favorite guitar, then rock super hard every time the other person talks. Your opponent can't win if no one hears them. Okay, maybe that's a little against the rules. We'll tell you about some non-guitar related strategies in this video.
Transcript
- 00:05
[Dino and Coop singing]
- 00:12
Debating might seem pretty easy.
- 00:15
After all, it's basically just two people talking, and we all know how to talk, right? [Two girls speaking at podiums]
- 00:19
Wellllll….not quite.
- 00:21
It turns out debating's a little more complicated than just chatting it up with a pal. [Debate judges]
Full Transcript
- 00:25
Like most activities, it has its own special rules and customs that you need to understand [A guy in a referee shirt gives the winner a big trophy]
- 00:29
if you want to be a great debater.
- 00:31
You wouldn't just walk onto a football field and decide to be a quarterback without knowing [Guy looking a football confused]
- 00:35
a thing or two about football, right?
- 00:36
…well…unless you're a really big fan of being tackled constantly… [Guy is piled on by the other team]
- 00:39
Anyway, one thing that's important to know is that speakers usually get about three minutes
- 00:43
at a time to present parts of their argument. [Dino next to a blackboard]
- 00:45
So if one of your points depends on you reading some really long Russian novel, you might [Two guys at podiums with a timer ticking down behind them]
- 00:50
want to rethink that bit of your argument.
- 00:53
It's also a good idea to stay quiet and respectful whenever it's your opponent's turn to speak.
- 00:58
Fair is fair, after all!
- 01:00
You wouldn't want someone talking, or yelling, or shooting off fireworks while you were speaking, [One of the guys making stupid faces whilst the other looks annoyed]
- 01:04
right?
- 01:05
…okay…maybe the fireworks thing would look cool… [Fireworks going off at the debate]
- 01:06
Ahem.
- 01:07
Moving on…
- 01:08
When it's your time to speak, remember to speak slowly and clearly, so that people can
- 01:12
hear and understand everything you say.
- 01:14
Remember, it's not a race. [Girl talking very fast]
- 01:16
Or a…whispering contest.
- 01:17
Do those exist?
- 01:19
We'd totally win….
- 01:21
When it comes to the structure of the debate, each of the debaters gets time to give their [JFK giving a speech]
- 01:25
opening statements.
- 01:26
Next, the debaters present their arguments.
- 01:28
After that, each debater tries to disprove the arguments presented by their opponent.
- 01:32
And, last but not least, each debater gets a chance to summarize their position, take
- 01:36
any last swipes at their opponent's counterarguments, and present the strongest possible version
- 01:41
of their position.
- 01:42
It can get pretty intense. [Boys looking angry]
- 01:43
We recommend you bring some popcorn to munch on. [Meter going up]
- 01:46
When it comes to what you actually say in a debate, clarity is your best friend. [Glass smashes]
- 01:50
Seriously, make it a BFF bracelet or something. [Someones wrist with a BFF bracelet]
- 01:53
After you're done making the bracelet, be sure to go over your argument in detail, using [Man reading over arguments with a magnifying glass]
- 01:57
analogies and examples so that your audience has a clear understanding of what you're arguing.
- 02:02
It's also a good idea to have three arguments for your position. [Man fighting off dragons]
- 02:06
That not only makes your argument seem more convincing… [3 dragons named arguments 1,2,3]
- 02:08
…but it forces your opponent into disproving lots of arguments.
- 02:11
The more work they have to do, the better for you. [Guy asleep]
- 02:14
That said, this is a debate, so you can't just throw out all your arguments and kick [Someone chucks water over the man sleeping]
- 02:17
back with a cool drink.
- 02:18
When it's your turn to rebut your opponent's arguments, keep things clear and concise…
- 02:22
…using more facts and examples to knock your opponent's ideas to the ground. [Guy holding a baseball bat that says facts and examples]
- 02:27
Follow this guide to debating, and you'll be debating like a pro in no time. [Debate champion crown on the guys head]
- 02:30
You might even be able to convince opposing football teams to never tackle you. [Football team chasing the guy holding the ball]
- 02:34
Although we wouldn't bet on it…. [The guy is tacked to the floor]
- 02:37
Ouch.
- 02:38
You okay there, bud…?
Up Next
Check out the best bias video ever made, courtesy of the most awesome and amazing educational website in existence.
Related Videos
No, this isn't a terrible new mint-peach bubble gum flavor...though it does tend to leave a bad taste in people's mouths.
Those settlers in Jamestown really should have settled down with all that land-stealing. Tobacco's bad for you anyway.
Being born out of multiple wars doesn't quite seem to fit the peaceful, polite Canadians we know and love today...oh wait, they were called The Bea...
Not every cartoon is meant to entertain small children while their mother gets some "Mommy time." There are also political cartoons, which are mean...